Carlos

Our discussion went well,we talk about our favorite parts.My favorite part was when Sam stole the brown Bess because he wanted it to go fight in the war,They argued about it but the next day the brown Bess was gone,Sam had taken it to war.We discussed about the part when Tim found his brother sleeping on the floor in front of the chimney and he had the brown Bess next to him.Tim made a run for it with the brown Bess then suddenly he amid at his brother Sam.We really liked this book because of how Tim and his father made the book sound interesting when they got in a fight with the cow boys which are stealer's beat up Tim's dad because he doesn't want to give the cattle to them.The discussion went really well.

RAMON

the part that i like was when sam took his fater brown bres so he went to war and tim got worried and bety and she told him that sam wasn,t coming home that he went to war to fight

cecilio

1. What I think was more important was when they almost got robbed on the way to sell their cattle.The cowboys wanted to steal their cattle and they were about to steal them but Tim ran so the cowboy's went to chase him but other people came to help them. The cowboys saw the other people so they left and Tim and his dad did not got robbed .Tim's dad told Tim to do not call them cowboys to call them stealer's because that's what their are.

2. My group discussion went well because when we were talking everyone participated and said what was their favorite part . My favorite part was when they almost got robbed on the way to sell their cattle and that was David's favorite part too. Their were no problem's on my book club discussion everyone did ok on the book talk.I would not change nothing of what were doing for now.

Carlos

What i tought was important about what i just read was that Tim and his father were attacked by cowboys that wanted to steal their cattle.Tim,s father was trying to protect the cattle but they beat up his father and they left.When they left they hurry,d up to there cousins house.When they go there they cleand up fathers blood and went to go talk with Tim and father.They had to sleep on a ranch in night when it was warm.

David B.

My favorite part was when Sam stole the gun called brown Bess from his father, because that was when Sam and Tim acuity got into there first conflict. To me that was just a very thrilling off the seat action because they Dru blood from each other.

My dissection was very fine we had no problems and I thought we got to the point in the shortest most direct way.

DAMEON

That Sam father was getting bet up some solider because they wanted the gun one of the solider told Sam to go in his room because they didn't want him to see his father get bet up .




all of us talked about the story .Then we asked each other question about the story after doing all that we set are new goal then we grader are folder and went back at are seats.after we sate in are seat we start to read. then we start to write about the story.

Anthony Alvarado

1. My favorite part when Sam trick the cowboy's into thinking that the officer's set an ambush on them then the cowboy's start to get scared and ran.
2. Our discussion whent good no one disturbed we each had part to say

David.M

1.What did i wonder about while i was reading is that wen i read is that i like the book is that wen Timmy was sad because father was mad at Sam because Sam all ways do some thing bad.

So Timmy wants Sam to live but their father douse not like it wen Sam talks about the Battle so that's why father kick Sam out the house.AND Sam got mad at father so Sam did not had a place to stay so this black guy help Sam to stay at his house.THan Sam went to fight but Timmy was sad that he may not see Sam anymore.So father got mad at Sam for taking the family gun so father went to go find Sam but Timmy wanted to go to so father take Timmy with him but wen they went to go look for Sam two cowboys than they told Timmy and father to kit of the horses so Timmy did but father did not so than they start to hit father on the hand with there guns so than father fell from the hoers.THan Timmy told him to stop but the cowboy look at Timmy than cowboy aim at father with the gun but Timmy told him to stop the Cowboy did not look at Timmy so Timmy went to go look for some help so he found some help than they help father but the cowboys start to run.THan father was OK than him and Timmy still went on but father was bleeding from the head so father did not care so thy went on and on but they stop to eat than they wen on.





2. So we talk about the book than we start to talk about the pages we read than we start to talk than we all like the pages that we read so we have to read to chapter 7 than we all start to read the book to chapter 7.

Sam

1. My favorite part of the book was when the Patriots came to Tims house and forced Eliphalet ( Tims father) to give them the Brown Bess.

The reason I like this part was because it was full of action because the Patriots cut Eliphalet cheek and almost attempted to kill him.



2. I was not here on Wednesday February 3, 2009 for my book club meeting.

D